Stillwater's Best Dessert [Updated 2026]

I’ve scoured the streets, indulging in everything from towering cakes to delicate pastries, and after tasting my way through 12 of the most talked-about spots, I’m ready to dish on my favorites. Each bite has been a delightful adventure, and I can’t wait to share the sweet discoveries I’ve unearthed.

With a discerning palate honed by years of tasting and a passion for all things sugary, you can trust that I’ve chosen only the most delectable treats for you. Whether you're a local or just passing through, these dessert destinations will have you swooning and craving more. Let’s dive into the sugary side of Stillwater!

Blue Spruce

Highlights
Amazing dairy-free sorbets
Smoothest drip coffee
Great atmosphere with music
Delicious gelato offerings
Highly recommended by locals

Blue Spruce has quickly become a standout destination for dessert lovers, and let me tell you, it deserves every bit of its acclaim! As soon as I stepped inside, the cozy atmosphere enveloped me, accompanied by a delightful playlist that set the perfect mood for indulging in sweet treats.

Now, let’s talk about the desserts. The gelato offerings are a revelation! Smooth and creamy, each spoonful melts in your mouth and transports you to a world of flavor. But what truly caught my attention were the dairy-free sorbets. These vibrant, refreshing options are bursting with natural sweetness, proving that indulgence doesn't have to mean sacrificing health. I tried a tropical mango sorbet that was so refreshing, I can still feel the sunshine radiating from every bite!

Of course, I can’t overlook their smoothest drip coffee, which pairs beautifully with the sweetness of the desserts. It was the perfect complement to my delightful afternoon. Locals rave about this gem, and after my visit, I can totally see why! If you're hunting for the best dessert in Stillwater, Blue Spruce is an absolute must-visit. Treat yourself—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Oklahoma City.

Frios Gourmet Pops - Stillwater,Oklahoma

Highlights
Super nice customer service
Drive-thru convenience
Lovely outdoor seating
Affordable popsicle pricing
Fun date idea

Frios Gourmet Pops - Stillwater, Oklahoma is a delightful gem that every dessert lover must visit. From the moment I approached the drive-thru, I was met with super nice customer service that instantly put me in a bright mood. The friendliness here is a signature touch that elevates the entire experience.

The outdoor seating is simply lovely, making it an ideal spot to enjoy your icy treat while soaking up the sun. I tried a few of their pops, and I was impressed by the wide range of flavors offered — from classics like strawberry to gourmet options that weave in unexpected ingredients. The popsicles are deliciously creamy and bursting with flavor; a perfectly refreshing dessert for any time of day.

What truly delights me is the affordable pricing. At Frios, you can indulge without breaking the bank, which is a rare find these days! Whether you're planning a fun date idea or just want to treat yourself, Frios Gourmet Pops has you covered. Overall, this sweet haven absolutely deserves its place among the best desserts in Stillwater. Don't miss their pops—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Oklahoma City.

Good Little Eater

Highlights
Charming mom-and-pop eatery
Fresh homemade ingredients
Delicious, diverse cookies
Weekly changing menu
Cozy, peaceful atmosphere

Good Little Eater is a delightful little gem nestled in the heart of Stillwater. As I stepped inside, I was immediately enveloped by a cozy and peaceful atmosphere that sets the perfect backdrop for indulging my sweet tooth. The charming mom-and-pop vibe really emphasizes their commitment to quality, and it shows in every bite.

The star of the show, of course, was their collection of diverse cookies. Made with fresh homemade ingredients, each cookie is a testament to their craft. I savored the rich, gooey chocolate chip variety, which boasted a perfect balance of crisp edges and a chewy center that left me wanting more. The best part? The menu changes weekly, ensuring that even regular visitors like myself always have the chance to try something new and exciting.

Every visit to Good Little Eater feels like visiting a friend’s house for a sweet treat—each cookie tells a story of care and creativity. If you find yourself in Stillwater and crave dessert that’s both indulgent and heartwarming, do not miss out on this charming spot. Good Little Eater is nothing short of a small slice of heaven!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in Oklahoma City.

Zannotti's Wine Bar

Highlights
Charming street-side patio
Delicious duck nachos
Great gluten-free options
Berry smash mocktail favorite
Caring and attentive staff

Zannotti's Wine Bar is a true gem nestled in the heart of Stillwater, and I had the pleasure of indulging in their delightful dessert offerings during my visit. Upon entering, the ambiance transported me to a cozy European enclave, complete with a charming street-side patio that sets the perfect stage for a sweet escape.

As I perused the menu, I couldn't help but savor every morsel of their delicious duck nachos—a worthy appetizer that whetted my appetite for what was to come. The highlight of the evening was, of course, the dessert. I opted for the seasonal berry tart, bursting with fresh, vibrant flavors that made each bite a joyous celebration. The flaky crust combined with creamy filling was a delightful contrast, and I can assure you, it left me dancing in my seat!

Accompanying my indulgence was their decadent berry smash mocktail, which perfectly complemented the sweetness of the dessert without overwhelming it. The staff were caring and attentive, enhancing my experience further. If you’re searching for the best dessert in Stillwater, look no further than Zannotti’s—a true treat that enchants the palate!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Oklahoma City.

Old School Bagel Cafe

Highlights
Varied vegetarian options
Friendly and sweet staff
Affordable lattes
Great breakfast on campus
Quick bite for students

Old School Bagel Cafe is a delightful find in the heart of Stillwater, and it’s not just for breakfast lovers. As I strolled in, I was greeted by the friendly staff, whose smiles were as warm as the bagels cooling behind the counter. While their bagel sandwiches are the stars of the show, it was their desserts that truly stole my heart.

I opted for a slice of their chocolate chip cookie cake, a delectable creation that melded the chewy goodness of cookies with a rich frosting layer. Each bite was a playful dance of textures, combining soft cake and a slight crunch from the cookies. It was not just a treat; it felt like a hug for my taste buds!

Beyond their desserts, the café boasts an impressive menu of vegetarian options and affordable lattes, making it a perfect stop for students or anyone seeking a quick bite. And their breakfast offerings? Unparalleled, with plenty of hearty choices.

In a town brimming with sweet spots, Old School Bagel Cafe may just take the cake—literally! If you're in Stillwater, this café is a must-visit for an undeniable sweet experience.

You might also want to check out the best dessert in Oklahoma City.

Persimmon Hill Farm and Bakery

Nestled in the heart of Stillwater, Persimmon Hill Farm and Bakery is a delightful haven for dessert lovers. I indulged in their famous peach cobbler, and let me tell you, it felt like a warm hug on a chilly day! The sweetness of ripe peaches melded perfectly with a buttery, flaky crust, creating a symphony of flavors. Each bite was a dance of nostalgia, reminding me of my grandma's kitchen. Coupled with a scoop of homemade vanilla ice cream, this dessert is simply irresistible! If you're seeking a sweet escape, Persimmon Hill will certainly satisfy your cravings! 🍑✨

You might also want to check out the best thai food in Oklahoma City.

Dragonfly Desserts LLC

Tucked away in the heart of Stillwater, Dragonfly Desserts LLC is a whimsical haven for sweet enthusiasts. My taste buds danced with joy as I savored their signature lavender lemon tart, the perfect balance of floral notes and zesty brightness. The flaky crust was a delight, cradling a rich, creamy filling that was simply unforgettable. Each bite felt like a playful trip through a garden of flavors! Don’t miss their decadent chocolate mousse, which is luxuriously smooth and utterly indulgent. If you’re seeking a delightful adventure in dessert, Dragonfly is a must-visit spot to satisfy your sweet cravings!

You might also want to check out the best hibachi in Oklahoma City.

Stillwater Sweets Bakery

At Stillwater Sweets Bakery, I was immediately enchanted by the whimsical decor and the heavenly aroma of freshly baked treats. I indulged in their signature salted caramel brownie, which was a delightful blend of rich chocolate and decadent caramel, topped with a sprinkle of sea salt that danced on my palate. Each bite was an explosion of flavor, perfectly balanced between sweet and savory. The staff was not only friendly but genuinely passionate about their craft, making my visit even more enjoyable. If you’re on the hunt for a dessert delight, this charming bakery is a must-visit in Stillwater!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Oklahoma City.

Rocky Mountain Chocolate Factory

At Rocky Mountain Chocolate Factory, I was immediately enchanted by the aromatic embrace of freshly made confections. The selection of decadent chocolates was a feast for the eyes, but it was the caramel apples that captured my heart. Drenched in creamy caramel and coated in irresistible toppings, each bite is a delightful crunch followed by a burst of sweetness. The ambiance exudes comfort and nostalgia, making it a perfect spot for indulging in your sweet cravings. If you're on the hunt for a chocolatey treasure, this gem in Stillwater should be at the top of your list!

You might also want to check out the best place to eat in Edmond.

Red Rock Bakery & Deli

Stepping into Red Rock Bakery & Deli felt like a sweet hug in the heart of Stillwater. Their cinnamon rolls are a must-try—fluffy, warm, and topped with a heavenly cream cheese glaze that practically sings with each bite. The baked goods showcase a delightful blend of creativity and tradition, making every visit an adventure for the taste buds. Don't overlook their seasonal pastries, which add a whimsical touch. With a cozy ambiance and the aroma of freshly baked delights permeating the air, Red Rock truly deserves a spot in the running for the best dessert in town! 🍰

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Norman.

Smallcakes: A Cupcakery & Creamery

Upon stepping into Smallcakes, the delightful aroma of freshly baked cupcakes enveloped me, igniting my sweet tooth. The signature flavors, like their velvety red velvet and blissful cookie dough, are nothing short of heavenly. Each cupcake is topped with a swirl of rich frosting that practically sings with joy. But the real showstopper? Their homemade ice cream—creamy, dreamy, and oh-so-decadent! I savored a scoop of salted caramel that was perfectly balanced and utterly indulgent. Smallcakes is a sweet spot that delivers both taste and charm, making it a top contender for the best dessert in Stillwater!

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in Oklahoma City.

Shortcake's Diner

Shortcake's Diner in Stillwater is a delightful haven for dessert enthusiasts! As I stepped inside, the nostalgia enveloped me, and the menu dazzled me with tempting options. I opted for their signature strawberry shortcake, and it did not disappoint. Each fluffy layer was generously dressed with fresh, succulent strawberries and a whipped cloud of cream that melted in my mouth. The balance of flavors was simply divine! The warm ambiance and friendly staff made the experience even sweeter. If you have a craving for something delectable, Shortcake's Diner deserves a top spot on your dessert list!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Oklahoma City.